Stop Press: The Bath House, Le Cateau Road, Colchester CO2 7NA – Let to Ellisons Solicitors. See our News Page for information on this innovative project.

Community Infrastructure Levy – CIL

Community Infrastructure Levy – CIL

Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) – two recent appeal decisions

Written on 24/04/2018 by Holmes and Hills, Solicitors www.holmes-hills.co.uk

We continue to see CIL issues, including draconian measures applied for what a lay person may consider to be inconsequential or innocent breaches. Where CIL is concerned however, the appeal decisions increasingly demonstrate that the law is the law and, unless there is strict compliance, the end result is usually unsuccessful appeals as far as surcharges and CIL penalties are concerned.

This is perhaps as best illustrated by two recent Planning Inspectorate decisions.

In the first the alleged failures were to assume liability for the Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) and the failure to submit a commencement notice before commencing works on chargeable development. Although the appellant acknowledged that he did fail to assume liability or submit a commencement notice, he alleged that this was because he received poor and confusing communication in telephone conversations with the collecting authority (‘Council’).  In simple terms, it was the Appellant’s case that had he received clear guidance the situation would have been avoided.

The Inspector found that “In the absence of any documentary evidence before me it is not possible to conclude that the appellant was given confusing or incorrect information regarding his CIL responsibilities. I can only consider the appeal on the known facts”. The facts were very much that the Appellant had failed to comply with the statutory requirements, with the Inspector further commenting “it was clear from the correspondence that the appellant was in danger of having to pay surcharges if he did not comply with the requests for submission of the notices. I consider the appellant’s decision to ignore these warnings was a risky strategy to take”.

The appeal was therefore dismissed and the Appellant required to pay the CIL surcharges levied by the Council.

In the second the allegation was that the Council has issued a Demand Notice with an incorrectly determined deemed commencement date. The description of the development in the grant of permission clearly included demolition. The Appellant acknowledged that demolition works had commenced but argued that they were only carried out to enable retaining wall structures to be constructed in relation to the planning permission and did not commence works on the CIL development.

Regulation 7(2) CIL explains that development is to be treated as commencing on the earliest date on which any material operation begins to be carried out on the relevant land. Section 56(2) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (TCPA 1990) explains that development shall be taken to be begun on the earliest date on which any material operation comprised in the development begins to be carried out. Section 56(4) TCPA gives examples of what “material operation” means and includes “any work of demolition of a building”.

The result? The appeal was dismissed. The Inspector was satisfied that there has been a deemed commencement and, absent the Appellant submitting a commencement notice, the council could impose a surcharge – which the Appellant was liable to pay.

We have emphasised before the importance of complying with the CIL Regs and being clear about deadlines and when, and which, forms need to be submitted etc. We do recommend that you obtain proof of submitting CIL forms etc. because (as explained at Holmes & Hills’  2017 Planning Law Update seminar series) a Planning Inspector is unlikely to help you out unless you can prove what was sent and when [so use emails or recorded delivery, or deliver in person and get receipts(!)], or what you were told and when [so keep a record of what has been said and by whom] and it is only this documentary evidence that could “save your bacon” at a later date.

That said, following Holmes and Hills’ input one London Borough has agreed that, despite its original position to the contrary, a valid request for abatement (or credit for CIL payments already made under one permission, permission A, towards another, permission B which was to be commenced in place of A moving forwards) was made and which, in practical terms means that the client is not required to pay just short of £30,000 twice over (i.e. once for permission A and once for B).

At Morley Riches & Ablewhite we are able to advise you of the impact of CIL on the viability of your development.  Speak to our expert on this subject, Peter Riches.

Our Services

Clients choose to work with our friendly, professional team time and time again because we consistently deliver a quality service that makes their lives easier. Our plain-speaking approach ensures everyone is kept on the same page and that a project can move forward in a timely and cost-effective way.

find-a-commercial-property-icon

Commercial Estate Agency

property-management-icon

Property Management

property-valuation-icon

Property Valuation

Landlord and Tenant

Building Surveying

Development Consultancy

What people say about working with us

  • "We have employed the services of Morley Riches & Ablewhite for over 10 years and have always found them to be Professional to deal with. Both Peter and Jon have a wide knowledge of the local commercial market which has enabled them to advise us on various aspects within our diverse business."
    Ian Newman, East Anglian Group
  • "I have known Peter Riches and indeed some of his staff for many years now.  Our family and I in particular have built a close relationship with Peter, instructing him on numerous occasions for projects, lease renewals, rent reviews etc. and have always found him to be honest, reliable and extremely efficient. Peter will always find a solution to all your property needs and matters – his creative talent, input and valuable knowledge is where he really shines above the rest “bar none”! I would have no hesitation in recommending him or his staff for all your property needs."
    Aaron Taub, Advantage Property Group
  • "Jon Ablewhite of Morley, Riches and Ablewhite has provided professional services to my company for many years. This has included sales, purchasing and renting of office properties in and around Colchester. He has been very professional and thorough, combining this with an understanding of the needs of a business client such as ourselves. Together with Peter Riches, he forms a very strong and likeable team."
    Russell Sainty, Seaford Properties Limited
  • "Morley, Riches & Ablewhite – forgettable name, but seriously unforgettable service! We engaged MRA about 3 years’ ago on recommendation.  We have never regretted it. Good, practical advice on all property aspects, including new leases, professional discussions with existing Landlords and advice generally. At all times the service has been prompt, professional and cost-effective.  Communication skills are first rate and we have confidence in the calibre of MRA’s team and their ability to provide commercial insight and evolve innovative win / win solutions."
    John May, Director, Thompson & Morgan Group Holdings Limited
  • "Peter Riches of MRA has managed an industrial property we own for the last 10 years and we have been delighted with the way our business has been handled. We have always found Peter to be very professional in his attitude; he has a good understanding of what we are trying to achieve, listens to our ideas and offers suggestions of his own. The rest of the team at MRA are always polite, friendly and helpful and we highly recommend the company and the services they offer."
    A J Kernahan, Developments Limited
  • "I have worked with Morley Riches and Ablewhite for several years. I have always found them to be trustworthy, professional, responsive and accurate while offering a flexible approach to problem solving. They provide excellent value for money and also deliver additional value through their thorough knowledge and network. Reputation and branding are important to any business so it’s important to select organisations who have a compatible constitution and culture. MRA demonstrate empathy with corporate objectives, they manage customer relationships effectively and efficiently and work seamlessly as part of a team. I would recommend them to anyone who needs a professional property service."
    Steve Heywood, Hills Building Group
Get In Touch

Get in touch

Email enquiries@mrallp.co.uk
Telephone 01206 505707

If you’ve got a question about the services we deliver, or would like some advice on how we can support your project, simply get in touch and we’d be more than happy to help.

Alternatively complete the form below for a member of our team to get in touch.

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Telephone (required)