Stop Press: The Bath House, Le Cateau Road, Colchester CO2 7NA – Let to Ellisons Solicitors. See our News Page for information on this innovative project.




The Court of Appeal has handed down its decision in the Mundy –v- The Trustees of the Sloane Stanley Estate [2018] EWCA Civ 35 on the issue of premiums for statutory residential lease extensions.
The point to be determined by the Court of Appeal was the issue of “relativity” when calculating the premium payable for the lease extension. Relativity has two aspects to it, the first is for the determination of the value of the freehold with vacant possession, and the second is the relationship between the value of a leasehold interest and the value of that interest on the assumption that the 1993 Act confers no right to acquire any interest in any premises containing the flat nor any new lease (in other words, that there is no right to a lease extension nor to participate in enfranchisement to acquire the freehold of the building).

The Judgment recognises that the problem with relativity arises because in the real world most sales of leasehold flats are sales of leases which have the right to a lease extension pursuant to the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, but the 1993 Act specifies that such rights are to be disregarded.

It is well known that the common method of determining relativity is by the use of graphs produced by chartered surveyors, although a number of different methods have been considered in the past. In the present case however, the Upper Tribunal considered the Parthenia Model, which is based on a statistical technique which begins with the proposition that the lease has a value which is made up of many component parts (including size, location and length of lease). It isolates each characteristic and gives a value to it.

When the Parthenia Model was applied in this case, it gave a value for the lease without rights under the 1993 Act which was higher than the value of the same lease with 1993 Act rights. The Court of Appeal said that was an impossible result, and agreed with the Upper Tribunal that the Parthenia Model should be rejected. The Court of Appeal also agreed with the Upper Tribunal that the Parthenia Model should not be used in future cases.

As recorded in the Court of Appeal’s decision, the Law Commission have been asked to consider the simplification of valuations under the 1993 Act and perhaps “the holy grail will one day be found”.

Panayiota Ioannou, Lead Property Litigation Solicitor at Debenhams Ottaway LLP, comments: “Whilst the Court of Appeal is hopeful of a resolution to the confusion in the future, it seems that the Law Commission has a difficult task ahead of it. Indeed, the Court of Appeal’s decision comments that the RICS’ working group was unable to produce a definitive graph in the past. It would therefore seem that substantive reform or definitive guidance is required. In the meantime, leaseholders and landlords alike are advised to obtain valuation advice from specialist surveyors and solicitors to ensure that they are given a range of realistic premium figures so as to be satisfied that the correct premium figure is arrived at.”
Morley Riches & Ablewhite are experienced in acting for leaseholders and landlords and can provide the relevant valuation advice. Contact Peter Riches on 01206 505709  e: to ensure you receive the specialist guidance you need.

Our Services

Clients choose to work with our friendly, professional team time and time again because we consistently deliver a quality service that makes their lives easier. Our plain-speaking approach ensures everyone is kept on the same page and that a project can move forward in a timely and cost-effective way.


Commercial Estate Agency


Property Management


Property Valuation

Landlord and Tenant

Building Surveying

Development Consultancy

What people say about working with us

  • "We have employed the services of Morley Riches & Ablewhite for over 10 years and have always found them to be Professional to deal with. Both Peter and Jon have a wide knowledge of the local commercial market which has enabled them to advise us on various aspects within our diverse business."
    Ian Newman, East Anglian Group
  • "Peter Riches of MRA has managed an industrial property we own for the last 10 years and we have been delighted with the way our business has been handled. We have always found Peter to be very professional in his attitude; he has a good understanding of what we are trying to achieve, listens to our ideas and offers suggestions of his own. The rest of the team at MRA are always polite, friendly and helpful and we highly recommend the company and the services they offer."
    A J Kernahan, Developments Limited
  • "Jon Ablewhite of Morley, Riches and Ablewhite has provided professional services to my company for many years. This has included sales, purchasing and renting of office properties in and around Colchester. He has been very professional and thorough, combining this with an understanding of the needs of a business client such as ourselves. Together with Peter Riches, he forms a very strong and likeable team."
    Russell Sainty, Seaford Properties Limited
  • "Griffin Chapman has a long-standing relationship with Morley Riches & Ablewhite. Our experience is that they are highly professional, efficient and proactive. We have been pleased to recommend a number of our clients to Morley Riches & Ablewhite for assistance in property matters. The feedback that we have received has been highly positive. We have also been pleased to co-sponsor a number of successful corporate events with Morley Riches & Ablewhite over recent years."
    Griffin Chapman, Chartered Accountants
  • "I have worked with Morley Riches and Ablewhite for several years. I have always found them to be trustworthy, professional, responsive and accurate while offering a flexible approach to problem solving. They provide excellent value for money and also deliver additional value through their thorough knowledge and network. Reputation and branding are important to any business so it’s important to select organisations who have a compatible constitution and culture. MRA demonstrate empathy with corporate objectives, they manage customer relationships effectively and efficiently and work seamlessly as part of a team. I would recommend them to anyone who needs a professional property service."
    Steve Heywood, Hills Building Group
  • "Being a local business in Colchester, we seek to establish relationships with local professionals in certain key areas of business. Morley Riches and Ablewhite are a professional friend of Handelsbanken and  understood from a very early stage what we were looking for from their reports. They  have been extremely prompt in their delivery  of valuations and more than happy to discuss all aspects of the property market within our catchment area, which we find very valuable.  Overall a pleasure to deal with."
    Russell Felstead, Handelsbanken
Get In Touch

Get in touch

Telephone 01206 505707

If you’ve got a question about the services we deliver, or would like some advice on how we can support your project, simply get in touch and we’d be more than happy to help.

Alternatively complete the form below for a member of our team to get in touch.

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Telephone (required)